Wow! It’s been busy since the last Hot Stove update and there was a third update that was never published due to the site’s server moves. All of those moves will be captured in this latest update and check back next Monday for the most complete offseason transaction update since BDD. Consider it, BDD’s Christmas present to you.

Since the second update, the Yankees took a plunge to the bottom of the rankings on the heels of the Mike Mussina retirement announcement. Then, the Yankees rebounded with the signing of CC Sabathia and A.J. Burnett. Despite the two gigantic signings, the other team from New York moved to the top of the rankings. The Mets received high marks for the signing of Francisco Rodriguez and fared the best of the three teams in the three-team, 12-player trade that landed the Mets J.J. Putz.

The Angels finally took a tumble from the top spot and can no longer live on their early option moves to bring back Vladimir Guerrero and John Lackey. Even with the loss of K-Rod, the Angels only slipped to #3. The San Francisco Giants continued to climb and cracked the Top 5 at #4 with the Cubs rounding out the Top 5.

Other teams who made big jumps were the Phillies who jumped from #15 to #7, the D-backs who jumped from #25 to #10, the Orioles who moved up six spots to #13 and the Dodgers who went from #26 to #15.

On the bottom of the rankings are the Milwaukee Brewers who lost Sabathia and went from #11 to #30 not only finding their way to the bottom but dropping 19 spots. The Reds moved up one spot but are still in the Bottom 5 at #29. Seattle stayed at #28 even after losing J.J. Putz and Raul Ibanez. The Toronto Blue Jays dropped 18 spots from #9 to #27 after A.J. Burnett’s departure became official. Rounding out the Bottom 5 was the Tampa Bay Rays who went from #22 to #26.

Other teams who experienced major slips were the Padres who went from #5 to #14, the White Sox who went from #14 to #21 and the Tigers who went from #17 to #24.

Enjoy the rest of the update below and check back next Monday for the most complete update of the offseason:

The third fourth in a series of offseason reports on Major League Baseball’s Hot Stove action. Each update, the BDD writers weigh in on the moves that will shape the Major League rosters of ’09.

Throughout the offseason, BDD will keep a running tally of all of the offseason moves and recap them by ranking the 30 Major League teams with recaps of the previous week’s moves for each team and select comments from the BDD team (click on picture to right to view all of team’s offseason moves to date):

1. New York Mets (Last Published Update - #2)

This Update’s Moves
- Signed Francisco Rodriguez to a 3-year, $37-million contract
- Traded for J.J. Putz, Sean Green and Jeremy Reed in a three-team, 12-player trade that sent Joe Smith to Cleveland and Aaron Heilman, Maikel Cleto, Jason Vargas, Endy Chavez, Mike Carp and Ezequiel Carrera to Seattle

Summary: If there was one thing the Mets needed to do at the Trade Deadline, it was acquire bullpen help. They made a half-hearted attempt after the deadline when they added Luis Ayala but it wasn’t enough. Now, with the free agent signing of the Major League’s record holder for most saves in a season, Rodriguez and a gamble on adding Putz to use as the team’s set-up man, the Mets look like they are on the move toward breaking through. However, that requires better play in September and we’re a long way away from September.

On adding Francisco Rodriguez:
“K-Rod picked a bad year to break the saves record. The Mets aren’t complaining that he wasn’t excessively expensive.” – Rob McQuown
“Mets will hope that K-rod and his agent weren’t lying about why he’s been losing velocity on his fastball.” – Matt Sisson
“Some may question K-Rod’s velocity, but he’s still a huge upgrade for the Mets and their overhauled pen.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Right station but is it the wrong train?” – Brian Joseph
“They got the closer they wanted, though how well he’ll pitch with the weight of the organization on his back is another question.” – Michael Street

On adding J.J. Putz:
“Many closers have trouble in non-save situations. If that doesn’t happen to Putz, the Mets will have a great 8-9 punch.” – Rob McQuown
“Putz will give the Mets as solid bridge to their closer and will remedy the bullpen woes in New York that lost 14 games for the Mets in 08.” – Matt Sisson
“Another quality arm added to the revamped bullpen. Also provides K-Rod insurance.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Right train wrong station?” - Brian Joseph
“If K-Rod spontaneously combusts, they’ve always got Putz. Having both is either overcautious, greedy, or overkill.” – Michael Street

On adding Sean Green:
“Useful, cheap ROOGY.” – Rob McQuown
“A groundballer who’s either fatigued or no longer fooling batters, Green might rebound in the NL—or continue to slide.” – Michael Street

On adding Jeremy Reed:
“Failed prospect is only slightly better than replacement level.” – Rob McQuown
“Reed’s a fourth outfielder or a platooner, and a good bat off the bench against righties.” – Michael Street

On losing Joe Smith:
“Was one of few solid bullpen options for Mets in 08.” – Joe Hamrahi
“They lose Smith and gain Green, who looks like Smith might in five years.” – Michael Street

On losing Aaron Heilman:
“The Mets had completely given up on using him as a SP, so the loss isn’t very great.” – Rob McQuown
“Change of scenery was necessary. Could excel in Seattle.” – Joe Hamrahi
“I know a few Mets fans that would chip in for the plane ticket. They’ll be the same Mets fans that curse Minaya if Heilman rebounds. It’s just what Mets fans do.” – Brian Joseph
“Cut loose after one bad season, Heilman might rebound with another team.” – Michael Street

On losing Maikel Cleto:
“We’ll know in a few years if this was a big loss or not.” – Michael Street

On losing Jason Vargas:
“A still-young arm who once showed a lot of promise. Vargas could be missed significantly on a team in need of SP.” – Rob McQuown
“Oft-injured, Vargas wasn’t giving the Mets much they can’t replace elsewhere.” – Michael Street

On losing Endy Chavez:
“An impact defender whose bat keeps him out of the lineup.” – Rob McQuown
“Chavez makes the highlight reels on defense, which is about all they’ll miss from him.” – Michael Street

On losing Mike Carp:
“Carp’s better suited as a platoon DH, and not a good full-time 1B, since he can’t hit lefties.” – Michael Street

On losing Ezequiel Carrera:
“It’s to soon to tell if they’ll miss Carrera, whose biggest asset is his speed and defense.” – Michael Street

2. New York Yankees (Last Published Update - #10)

This Update’s Moves
- Sold Darrell Rasner to Japanese Professional team
- Mike Mussina retired
- Signed CC Sabathia to a 7-year, $161-million contract
- Signed A.J. Burnett to a 5-year, $82.5-million contract

Summary: Money definitely talks and the Yankees proved it again as the Bombers landed the top free agent on the market with the addition of Sabathia. Then they added the consolation prize of Burnett late in the week to further boost their rotation. To say the Yankees did a good job in filling their rotation holes created by the retirement of Mussina and the unsure status of free agent Andy Pettite is an understatement. Based on rumors churning throughout the mill, it looks like the Yankees are far from done.

On adding CC Sabathia:
“Just what the doctor ordered! Far more important to this team’s situation than Teixeira would have been.” – Rob McQuown
“7 years for any pitcher seems ridiculous. The Yankees don’t care about how much money they spend or waste so they’re willing to take risks.” – Matt Sisson
“Big man on the big stage with a big wallet.” – Joe Hamrahi
“He won’t have to pitch 250 innings in New York and is as good as it gets these days. Seven years is a lot but he’ll only be 35 at the end of the contract. The Yankees just bought themselves 105 wins over the next seven years… at least.” – Brian Joseph
“Everyone else looks at Sabathia and sees Pedro Martinez, but I see Bartolo Colon, another overweight fireballer who collapsed after a heavy workload. The Yanks will regret this contract” – Michael Street

On adding A.J. Burnett:
“After he used the opt-out which Toronto inexplicably gave him, the Yanks also bank on the oft-injured pitcher’s health.” – Rob McQuown
“New York continues to throw money at its problems but Burnett may be another Wright/Pavano signing for NY. He’s topped 180 innings just 3 times in his career.” – Matt Sisson
“Is AJ worth it? No, of course not. But someone had to pay to get him. And the Yankees have the dough!” – Joe Hamrahi
“If Burnett lives up to this contract, I will walk from my home in Delaware to New York City. Last time I said something like this, it was about Manny Ramirez and the possibility of him being traded to the Dodgers. My memory fails me on exactly what I said though.” – Brian Joseph
“Burnett isn’t durable, isn’t consistent, but everyone drools over those strikeout numbers. We’ll see if he straightens out in pinstripes.” – Michael Street

On the retirement of Mike Mussina:
“It’s going to be difficult to replace 20 wins on a staff that struggled to begin with. But the Yankees have dollars and CC, Lowe, and Burnett are all still free agents.” – Joe Hamrahi
“This is called going out in style.” – Brian Joseph
“Truly the Yankees’ ace in 2008. I think he’ll pull a Favre still, and be back in 09.” – Rob McQuown
“Moose had a fine 2007 and they’ll miss him on and off the field, but he didn’t have too many more good years in him–if any.” – Michael Street

On losing Darrell Rasner:
“5.40 ERA and 1.5+ WHIP. Wasn’t he the Yankees’ ace in 2008? J Won’t be missed (much).” – Rob McQuown
“Losing him overseas instead of a trade means they don’t get anything in return, but Rasner wasn’t too good last year. He might be better down the road.” – Michael Street

3. Los Angeles Angels (Last Published Update - #1)

This Update’s Moves
- Signed Pil Joon Jang to a Minor League contract
- Lost Francisco Rodriguez to the Mets via free agency

Summary: The Angels took a big hit with the gaping hole created by the loss of their closer to the Mets but they scored so well by exercising the options on Vladimir Guerrero and John Lackey they stayed in the Top 5. If the Angels can’t hold on to Mark Teixeira though, expect their offseason stock to drop dramatically. Reportedly, the club offered Teixeira an 8-year deal but will that be enough with many other teams including the Red Sox, Nationals, Orioles and Yankees interested. They will also be penalized when Garret Anderson signs elsewhere, a move that looks likely.

On adding Pil Joon Jang:
“Jang, a 20-year-old righty is one of the latest South Korean additions to the Angels organization.” – Michael Street

On losing Francisco Rodriguez:
“Underlying stats weren’t stellar, but he’ll still be sorely missed.” – Rob McQuown
“LA should be able to fill K-Rods shoes from within without any problems.” – Matt Sisson
“The Angels will have to figure out who will replace 60+ saves…not an easy task.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Generally, K-Rod was looked at as overrated and not that difficult to replace. Hard to believe that a guy who saved 60-plus is that overrated or easy to replace and generally people are wrong.” – Brian Joseph
“Closers aren’t as valuable as some commentators think, but K-Rod is still a big loss.” – Michael Street

4. San Francisco Giants (Last Published Update - #17)

This Update’s Moves
- Signed Jeremy Affeldt to a 2-year, $8-million contract
- Signed Bob Howry to a 1-year, $2.75-million contract
- Signed Edgar Renteria to a 2-year, $18.5-million contract
- Lost Brad Hennessey to the Orioles via free agency

Summary: The Giants have added some talent to their young roster and with a few more additions might have to be taken seriously in the NL West especially if the Dodgers take steps backward. The addition of Affeldt and Howry to the bullpen should help San Francisco’s ‘pen improve and the addition of Renteria to the infield is an upgrade.

On adding Jeremy Affeldt:
“Good arm but a lot of money for a team that needs to score runs before its bullpen can hold on and save games.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Giants can afford him, and at least they’re looking at the right things now, such as ‘peripheral stats.’” – Rob McQuown
“He’s good, but not $4M-per-year good.” – Michael Street

On adding Bob Howry:
“Good peripherals, good risk at the price.” – Rob McQuown
“San Fran hopes they get the Howry of 2005, and not the one of 2008.” – Michael Street

On adding Edgar Renteria:
“Defense has abandoned him, and older shortstops very rarely hit. Renteria won’t earn his salary.” – Rob McQuown
“May just be that Renteria plays better in the NL.” – Matt Sisson
“Renteria looked better in the NL, and San Fran is sure banking on that. They’ll regret paying this much when he’s 35.” – Michael Street

On losing Brad Hennessey:
“Affeldt will more than make up for the slight loss Hennesey might represent.” – Michael Street

5. Chicago Cubs (Last Published Update - #5)

This Update’s Moves
- Re-signed Ryan Dempter to a 4-year, $52-million contract
- Signed Chad Fox to a Minor League contract
- Acquired David Patton from the Reds for cash
- Lost Bob Howry to the Giants via free agency
- Lost Jose Reyes to the Orioles via waiver claim

Summary: The Cubs moved up three spots when they re-signed Dempster but slid back to #5 when they lost Howry and a couple of other teams did a bit more. With the loss of Howry, the Cubs bullpen is becoming a concern and this update doesn’t even capture the loss of Kerry Wood to the Cleveland Indians via free agency which should set them further back. Sure, they added Kevin Gregg earlier in the offseason but many are skeptical about his consistency.

On retaining Ryan Dempster:
“Relatively cheap.” – Bill Baer
“Dempster is likely to regress some, and the increase in IP makes him high-risk, but the price is a bargain for his potential.” – Rob McQuown
“Did Dempster turn a corner, or merely have a contract year? The Cubs gambled on the former, but I’m not convinced.” – Michael Street

On adding Chad Fox:
“Fox’s time in the big leagues has been over for a few years.” – Matt Sisson
“Fox hasn’t been any good in years. Are the Cubs this hard up for bullpen help?” – Michael Street

On adding David Patton:
“He’s been decent in A-ball, but is a little old for his level.” – Michael Street

On losing Bob Howry:
“Peripherals were strong enough to warrant keeping him, despite wearing out his welcome in 2008.” – Rob McQuown
“Howry has been slipping each of the past two years, and fell hard in 2008.” – Michael Street
“And the nominees for 2008’s Players In Need of a Change of Scenery award… Bob Howry!” – Brian Joseph

On losing Jose Reyes:
“A guy named “Geovany Soto” makes the loss of Reyes no big deal.” – Michael Street

6. Boston Red Sox (Last Published Update - #6)

This Update’s Moves
- Acquired Ramon Ramirez from the Royals for Coco Crisp
- Signed Junichi Tazawa to a 3-year, $3-million contract
- Lost David Ross to the Braves via free agency

Summary: It’s hard to measure the impact of the signing of Tazawa as his inexperience might not see him make an immediate impact but the move received decent marks from the BDD contributors. Overall, the trade of Crisp to the Royals for Ramirez scored as a plus for the Sox as well and the loss of Ross was seen as a very minor one. While the Bo Sox seem to be holding their own this offseason, the Yankees have done a lot to improve their club already and are currently sitting ahead of the Sox in the rankings.

On adding Ramon Ramirez:
“Adds a little something, but I don’t see the big fuss about this move…or Boston in general I guess.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Excellent peripherals after leaving Colorado. If it’s real improvement, Boston could have a nice setup guy.” – Rob McQuown
“Getting out of Colorado helped Ramirez achieve his potential. He’ll be good, but not great, at the back end of the Boston pen.” – Michael Street

On adding Junichi Tazawa:
“Will give Boston a chance to bring Tazawa up through their system and mold him into the pitcher they want him to be.” – Matt Sisson
“The Yankees and Red Sox are supposed to overspend on the big name free agents not pick up a young speculative talent at a decent price.” – Brian Joseph
“Who knows? These Far East pitchers are generally wildcards. I’ll put my faith in Boston knowing what they’re doing.” – Joe Hamrahi
“His impact will likely be greater off the field, but Tazawa could turn out to be a Japanese bargain.” – Michael Street

On losing Coco Crisp:
“Excess on Red Sox… won’t hurt them.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Crisp and his flashy glove will be missed, but he wasn’t cheap, Bay will miss fewer games than Manny, and Ellsbury can play CF well.” – Rob McQuown
“No longer cuckoo for Coco, Boston got some value for him. They’ll only miss him if Ellsbury continues to struggle.” – Michael Street

On losing David Ross:
“Hardly a superstar, but why would a team with a weakness at catcher allow him to go?” – Rob McQuown
“They hardly ever used Ross, and thus will hardly miss him.” – Michael Street

7. Philadelphia Phillies (Last Published Update - #15)

This Update’s Moves
- Acquired John Mayberry Jr. from the Rangers for Greg Golson
- Acquired Ronny Paulino from the Pirates for Jason Jaramillo
- Signed Raul Ibanez to a 3-year, $31.5-million contract

Summary: Newly appointed GM Ruben Amaro Jr. has already exchanged outfielders with the Rangers and catchers with the Pirates in an attempt to make slight upgrades. Both moves were seen as improvements although very minor ones for the Phillies. In addition to those trades, the Phillies filled their corner outfield need with Ibanez but since Pat Burrell has not moved on yet, it’s tough to say whether the BDD contributors will rate it as an upgrade. For now, the move was looked at as a plus.

On adding John Mayberry Jr.:
“Potentially a platoon partner in left field in the event Pat Burrell doesn’t re-sign with the Phillies.” – Bill Baer
“Regarded as a good hitter, but a .316 OBP at age 24 in the PCL doesn’t scream “star”. – Rob McQuown
“A good swap–Mayberry will be ready sooner than Golson, and they need corner power more than another centerfielder, especially if they lose Burrell.” – Michael Street

On adding Ronny Paulino:
“Fairly inconsequential, but he’s younger than the vets, and all three are holding the spot for Marson anyway.” – Rob McQuown
“Paulino’s a backup at this point in his career, and now he’s the third catcher in Philly.” – Michael Street
“Don’t be surprised if Paulino is a 2 and Coste plays a different role in ’09 or even goes elsewhere. The Phillies are satisfied with Ruiz now and Marson later.” – Brian Joseph

On adding Raul Ibanez:
“Amaro off to an inauspicious start, signing yet another lefty bat who may actually be a worse fielder than Burrell.” – Rob McQuown
“Good bat/poor glove…” – Matt Sisson
“As good as Burrell now but maybe not in that third year of the contract. Remember when the Phillies signed Danny Tartabull or Ron Gant or traded for Dale Murphy? We can even throw Geoff Jenkins into that list after his first year. Hopefully, that is not who Ibanez is.” – Brian Joseph
“Not big on another left-handed bat after Utley and Howard. Solid offense though.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Ibanez has been one of the most consistent RBI men in the past three seasons, but the lineup’s now stacked with lefties, and Ibanez isn’t getting any younger.” – Michael Street

On losing Greg Golson:
“Golson has more tools than Mayberry but doesn’t really fit in anywhere other than as a #5 outfielder in 2009 for the Phillies.” – Bill Baer
“Reminiscent of Michael Bourn and the Phillies didn’t really miss him in ’08.” – Brian Joseph
“Golson could be good someday, but it’ll be later rather than sooner, and Victorino is blocking his way.” – Michael Street

On losing Jason Jaramillo:
“Not as good as Marson so they sent him on his way.” – Brian Joseph

8. St. Louis Cardinals (Last Published Update - #12)

This Update’s Moves
- Signed Trever Miller to a 1-year, $500,000 contract
- Acquired Khalil Greene from the Padres for Mark Worrell
- Lost Felipe Lopez to the Diamondbacks via free agency

Summary: The Cardinals made some small pick-ups but lost Trade Deadline scoop Lopez. The addition of Greene might pay big dividends if he returns to his performance of the past few years. The 29-year-old short stop is an upgrade over last year’s SS Cesar Izturis offensively even if Greene turns in an offensive performance like he did in ’08.

On adding Trever Miller:
“A good price to pay for a better-than-average bullpen lefty.” – Michael Street
“In the current market for relievers, Miller is cheap.” – Brian Joseph

On adding Khalil Greene:
“No real reason to expect a breakout season from him, other than LaRussa often having that impact on guys.” – Rob McQuown
“Not really sure what to make of this move. LaRussa seems to revitalize careers like Greene’s.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Greene had a down year so the Cardinals were able to buy low. Buying low doesn’t always mean you ever get the opportunity to sell high though.” – Brian Joseph
“Greene’s surfer-boy look won’t look right outside of PETCO, but his power numbers will look a lot prettier.” – Michael Street

On losing Felipe Lopez:
“Losing Lopez leaves them with Kennedy as a starter, which is not a place the Cardinals want to be.” – Michael Street

On losing Mark Worrell:
“Viewed as a closer of the future, Worrell’s not a bad swap for Khalil Greene, and they needed a shortstop more than another stopper.” – Michael Street

9. Texas Rangers (Last Published Update - #9)

This Update’s Moves
- Acquired Greg Golson from the Phillies for John Mayberry Jr.
- Acquired Guillermo Moscoso and Carlos Melo to the Tigers for Gerald Laird
- Sold Kameron Loe to Japanese Professional team

Summary: The Rangers were expected to move at least one catcher this offseason and already have when they sent Laird to the Tigers for two prospects. It’s unlikely any of their recent additions will make major impacts in ’09 though and the Rangers still have yet to answer any of the questions created by their pitching staff’s poor performance last year.

On adding Greg Golson:
“Still very young, and his great athletic ability gives him serious upside. Very unlikely to reach it, but should at least play good D in CF.” – Rob McQuown
“A good trade for both teams; the Rangers need a centerfielder so they can move Hamilton to a corner spot, and Golson should be ready soon.” – Michael Street

On adding Guillermo Moscoso:
“A good, young arm who may soon see the crucible of Arlington.” – Michael Street

On adding Carlos Melo:
“Still too young, but it cannot hurt to collect guys like this. Upside is there.” – Rob McQuown
“Potential and youth is what you want when you trade away a piece you don’t need like Laird.” – Michael Street

On losing Kameron Loe:
“Loe defines the term “export quality”: good enough to send out of the country. He won’t be missed.” – Michael Street

On losing Gerald Laird:
“No loss at all.” – Rob McQuown
“Deep at catcher.” – Joe Hamrahi
“They’ve got Saltalamacchia and Teagarden, making Laird more than expendable.” – Michael Street

On losing John Mayberry Jr.:
“Mayberry wasn’t as good a fit for their future as Golson, though neither will be superstars.” – Michael Street

10. Arizona Diamondbacks (Last Published Update - #25)

This Update’s Moves
- Signed Felipe Lopez to a 1-year, $3.5-million contract
- Re-signed Augie Ojeda to a 1-year, $712,500 contract

Summary: One of the last teams to make a move, the D-backs brought Ojeda back into the fold and added Lopez to fill the potential void left if the club fails to re-sign Orlando Hudson. Lopez can also play short as well and the D-backs might use Lopez as the lead-off hitter.

On adding Felipe Lopez:
“Career OBP of .330 and lousy defense. Webb’s worst nightmare.” – Rob McQuown
“Like the bat, hate the glove. Arizona pitchers are going to be begging for defense this year.” – Joe Hamrahi
“A decent 2B option who flashes occasional pop and won’t embarrass himself with the glove, but he’s no O-Dog.” – Michael Street

On retaining Augie Ojeda:
“There’s a nice warm spot on the D-backs bench with Ojeda’s name on it, and Arizona fans hope it never gets too cool.” – Michael Street

11. Washington Nationals (Last Published Update - #3)

This Update’s Moves
- Lost Chris Schroder via waiver claim to the Athletics

Summary: The Nationals made waves last week when a rumor came out about the club possibly making a big time offer to Mark Teixeira. If the Nationals score Teixeira, Washington will have the power hitter they are looking for but he will come at a steep cost. The offer from the Nats was rumored to be somewhere in the area of 8 years and $20 million per year but nothing was confirmed. Since Washington stayed basically dormant since last update they took a tumble from their #3 spot down to #11.

On losing Chris Schroder:
“Note to the Nats: If a guy can play ball, protect him on your 40-man roster.” – Rob McQuown
“Can the Nats afford to lose any pitching? They can if it’s Schroder.” – Michael Street

12. Oakland Athletics (Last Published Update - #7)

This Update’s Moves
- Claimed Chris Schroder off waivers from the Nationals
- Lost Donnie Murphy via free agency to the Orioles

Summary: After making a lot of noise early, the Athletics were relatively quiet during the Winter Meetings with the exception of their pursuit of Rafael Furcal. It looks like their pursuit of Furcal will fall short and it is unknown where the Athletics will turn their attention to next.

On adding Chris Schroder:
“Excellent pickup for a waiver claim.” – Rob McQuown
“Bad in the majors, scarcely adequate in the minors, Schroder will get the mop when the game’s out of reach.” – Michael Street

On losing Donnie Murphy:
“No loss here, even if Oakland is lacking in middle infield depth.” – Michael Street

13. Baltimore Orioles (Last Published Update - #29)

This Update’s Moves
- Signed Brad Hennessey to a Minor League contract
- Signed Donnie Murphy to a Minor League contract
- Claimed Jose Reyes off waivers from the Cubs
- Acquired Ryan Freel, Justin Turner and Brandon Waring from the Reds for Ramon Hernandez
- Sent Louis Palmisano to the Astros for cash

Summary: Overall, the move that sent Hernandez to Cincinnati was well received by the BDD contributors. No one saw Hernandez as a major loss and the addition of Freel was seen as a positive one almost across the board. Waring and Turner were just a bonus.

On adding Brad Hennessey:
“Briefly the Giants’ closer in 2007, Hennessey will likely have some cachet as a result. He shouldn’t; he’s average at best.” – Michael Street

On adding Donnie Murphy:
“He can’t hit, he can’t field. Baltimore needs depth in the infield, but Murphy’s not the answer.” – Michael Street

On adding Jose Reyes:
“Hasn’t been all that impressive at the major-league level, but he’s still young.” – Michael Street

On adding Ryan Freel:
“Very useful player in the Chone Figgins mold.” – Rob McQuown
“Freel is more of a part time player but in Baltimore will increase his playing time.” – Matt Sisson
“Too fragile and is best as a utility player anyway.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Freel brings his wall-crashing ways to the Orioles, where he’ll play as long as he’s healthy.” – Michael Street

On adding Brandon Waring:
“Waring is a good baseball guy who could develop into a nice hot-corner option.” – Michael Street

On adding Justin Turner:
“Think Ryan Freel in the infield: no power, decent average, a scrappy, dirty-knees style of play–and a low performance ceiling.” – Michael Street

On losing Ramon Hernandez:
“Possibly the worst defensive catcher in MLB in 2008, highly paid if it wasn’t a fluky season.” – Rob McQuown
“The Matt Wieters era has begun in Baltimore.” – Matt Sisson
“Does this mean Wieters is pushed along?” – Joe Hamrahi
“Having been to a few post-game press conferences, this is not surprise. It seemed like Ramon’s stock was down and they got a decent return for him and cleared some payroll, too.” – Brian Joseph
“The O’s didn’t need Hernandez, whose salary no longer matches his skills, but they couldn’t dump his entire contract.” – Michael Street

On losing Louis Palmisano:
“As catching uber-prospect Matt Wieters shoots through their organization, the Orioles decided to dump the lesser Palmisano.” – Michael Street
“Pick up a guy in the Rule V draft and then send him off for some dough. Sounds good to me.” – Brian Joseph

14. San Diego Padres (Last Published Update - #4)

This Update’s Moves
- Acquired Mark Worrell from the Cardinals for Khalil Greene

Summary: The Padres cleared some payroll by moving Greene to the Cardinals but failed to pull the trigger on a deal to send Jake Peavy anywhere. At one point there was a rumor that Peavy would move in a three or four-way deal to the Cubs but that deal never happened. Instead, the Padres and Cubs are out of talks and Peavy is closer to staying in San Diego than going anywhere.

On adding Mark Worrell:
“Worrell’s a nice option at the back of the Padres bullpen, where they need plenty of help.” – Michael Street

On losing Khalil Greene:
“Khalil had great road stats for his career, but was horribly miscast in SD.” – Rob McQuown
“Greene’s pull-happy, power-riffic tendencies won’t be missed, but his defense will.” – Michael Street

15. Los Angeles Dodgers (Last Published Update - #27)

This Update’s Moves
- Signed Mark Loretta to a 1-year, $1.25-million contract
- Signed Casey Blake to a 3-year, $17-million contract
- Greg Maddux retired

Summary: The Dodgers have retained one of their two Trade Deadline acquisitions by bringing back Blake but there has been no progress on the Manny Ramirez front. However, Ramirez has received little interest in the open market which gives the Dodgers some leverage they did not have prior to the Winter Meetings. It has to sting a little that Nick Punto was a hotter commodity during the Winter Meetings than Manny. At least for Ramirez and super agent Scott Boras not the Dodgers.

On adding Mark Loretta:
“Should see a lot of playing time with the Dodgers infield.” – Rob McQuown
“A capable backup around the infield who can also pinch hit, Loretta won’t take the Dodgers to a title, but he’ll help.” – Michael Street

On adding Casey Blake:
“About a league-average hitter and defender at 3b.” – Rob McQuown
“Reasonable deal for Blake who still can help a big league club.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Not a bad price for a third-baseman with a little pop in his bat, but not a great price, either.” – Michael Street

On losing Greg Maddux:
“A great example of what’s good about baseball. This writer’s favorite player will be missed. So long Greg.” – Rob McQuown
“If only MLB put a team in Vegas in ’09, we might have seen him pitch one more year. He didn’t go out on top but at least he went out somewhere in the middle.” – Brian Joseph
“Not a big loss at this junction of his career.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Losing a first-ballot Hall-of-Famer is always bad, even if he’s past his prime.” – Michael Street

16. Houston Astros (Last Published Update - #18)

This Update’s Moves
- Signed Mike Hampton to a 1-year, $2-million contract
- Signed Matt Kata to a Minor League contract
- Claimed Jeff Fulchino off waivers from the Royals
- Acquired Louis Palmisano from the Orioles for cash
- Re-signed Doug Brocail to a 1-year, $2.75-million contract
- Lost Mark Loretta to the Dodgers via free agency

Summary: The Astros were busy but only the addition of Hampton and the re-signing of Brocail should have any type of serious impact. The addition of Hampton is a big question mark thanks to his injury-prone history. The moves made by the Astros were reflected as minimal impact by the BDD contributors also who only moved the ‘stros up two spots in the rankings.

On adding Mike Hampton:
“At $1 million per start ($2 million for the season), he will be a bit pricy. No, seriously, he’s a good gamble for this price.” – Rob McQuown
“Can Ed Wade get odds in Vegas on Hampton hitting the DL? If so, he should plunk down enough to cover Hampton’s salary because in the unlikely event he doesn’t catch the injury bug (again), the extra insurance would be worth it.” – Brian Joseph
“Incentive laden deal could give the Astros some value…if Hampton stays healthy.” – Joe Hamrahi

On adding Matt Kata:
“The ladies love Kata ’cause he’s a cutie. Why the Astros like him, too, is a mystery.” – Michael Street

On adding Jeff Fulchino:
“Picking up a guy with a 4.45 ERA, 1.45 WHIP in 876 minor league innings–ooh, there’s a steal!” – Michael Street

On adding Louis Palmisano:
“The Astros have lots of minor-league catching depth, this is a head-scratcher. Maybe they’re looking to corner the market.” – Michael Street

On retaining Doug Brocail:
“Lefties hit .305/.371/.486 against him in ‘08. The minors are replete with ROOGY candidates for the minimum.” – Rob McQuown
“Brocail is good, but old, and you’ve got to wonder how many innings are left in his arm.” – Michael Street

On losing Mark Loretta:
“He’ll be missed, but not too much.” – Rob McQuown
“The versatile Loretta started for the Astros all over the infield and hit fairly well, which they’ll miss.” – Michael Street

17. Colorado Rockies (Last Published Update - #13)

This Update’s Moves
None

Summary: The Rockies favorite movie during the Winter Meetings – All Quiet On The Western Front.

18. Atlanta Braves (Last Published Update - #21)

This Update’s Moves
- Signed David Ross to a 2-year, $3-million contract
- Acquired Javier Vazquez and Boone Logan to the White Sox for Brent Lillibridge, Tyler Flowers, Santos Rodriguez and Jon Gilmore
- Claimed Eric O’Flaherty off waivers from the Mariners
- Lost Mike Hampton to the Astros via free agency
- Lost Jorge Julio to the Brewers via free agency

Summary: The Braves were busy but no one was blown away by the additions of Ross, Vazquez, Logan and O’Flaherty compared to what they lost. The Braves did move a few spots up the rankings though and are headed in the right direction especially if the club re-signs Rafael Furcal.

On adding David Ross:
“Good complement for McCann, as he can throw and hits lefties.” – Rob McQuown
“Unless McCann turns into McCan’t, we won’t see Ross much, and Braves fans won’t want to.” – Michael Street

On adding Javier Vazquez:
“Arguably the most durable pitcher in MLB, better than his W-L indicates.” – Rob McQuown
“More durable than Peavy but nowhere near as exciting of a choice. The consolation prize isn’t bad but if I were the Mets or Phillies, I wouldn’t lose any sleep yet.” – Brian Joseph
“Will benefit from returning to the National League- should see a drop in ERA and an increase in K’s.” – Matt Sisson
“Should help the Atlanta rotation in an environment that won’t rattle him.” – Joe Hamrahi
“He’ll gobble up innings with the indifferent approach and results of the guy who got Honorable Mention at the county fair pie-eating contest.” – Michael Street

On adding Boone Logan:
“Underrated lefty with good stuff and peripherals. He’s a breakout candidate.” – Rob McQuown
“A big lefty with unrealized potential, he may end up having more value than Vazquez in this swap.” – Michael Street

On adding Eric O’Flaherty:
“Should be a decent LOOGY at worst. Very good talent for a waiver claim.” – Rob McQuown
“He had an awful 2008, but this lefty reliver was once one of the M’s top prospects. Savvy gamble by Atlanta.” – Michael StreetOn losing Brent Lillibridge:
“This may come back to haunt Atlanta. Brent is a scrappy player who could carve out a nice little career.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Whatever went wrong in 2008 with the once-highly rated Lillibridge, the Braves didn’t want to find out.” – Michael Street

On losing Tyler Flowers:
“Excellent hitting prospect, not nearly ready yet.” – Rob McQuown
“A promising C/1B with pop, his way was blocked by McCann.” – Michael Street

On losing Santos Rodriguez:
“Very lively arm, very high attrition rate for guys his age.” – Rob McQuown
“A young strike-throwing lefty–and another prospect Atlanta didn’t need to lose.” – Michael Street

On losing Jon Gilmore:
“Losing another high-ranking prospect in exchange for Vazquez is not the path to long-term glory.” – Michael Street

On losing Mike Hampton:
“He was on the Braves?” – Rob McQuown
“Was willing to sign for peanuts and return to the Braves but went elsewhere for peanuts and Cracker Jack. The Braves obviously don’t care if he ever gets back.” – Brian Joseph
“I’d say good riddance!” – Joe Hamrahi
“Getting out from under his $15M salary had to feel like a homeowner shedding an upside-down mortgage.” – Michael Street

On losing Jorge Julio:
“Losing Julio is one loss that will never hurt Atlanta.” – Michael Street

19. Minnesota Twins (Last Published Update - #24)

This Update’s Moves
- Re-signed Nick Punto to a 2-year, $8.5-million contract

Summary: The Twins retained Punto and not much else but the addition was good enough to move Minnesota of a few clubs although many of them went backward while the Punto move basically kept the Twins with the same grade.

On retaining Nick Punto:
“Acquitted himself well at SS for someone who hadn’t played there primarily since 2003. Punto made Everett expendable.” – Rob McQuown
“I don’t get paying $8.5 million for 2 years of this guy.” – Joe Hamrahi
“He must be really good in the clubhouse.” – Brian Joseph
“This offseason was supposed to be one of austerity, particularly for lower-end ballplayers. Guess Minnesota didn’t get that memo.” – Michael Street

20. Cleveland Indians (Last Published Update - #19)

This Update’s Moves
- Acquired Joe Smith from the Mets and Luis Valbuena from the Mariners in a three-way deal that sent Franklin Gutierrez to the Mariners
- Signed Tomo Ohka to a Minor League contract
- Sold Tom Mastny to a Japanese Professional team

Summary: The Indians played third wheel and the catalyst that sparked the 12-player trade between the Mariners, the Mets and themselves. In the deal, they were bit players and overall this offseason have made little impact. The next update should see them move forward as they signed Kerry Wood via free agency over the weekend and their stay in the bottom half of the rankings is likely to be over by Monday.

On adding Joe Smith:
“He’s a good groundballer whose accomplishments are less ordinary than his name suggests.” – Michael StreetOn adding Luis Valbuena:
“Valbuena might one day be the answer to their hole at 2B.” – Michael Street

On adding Tomo Ohka:
“999 career IP, 4.14 ERA (108 ERA+). For the price, he provides outstanding insurance at SP.” – Rob McQuown
“Ohka is a middling innings-eater who has caused some clubhouse problems in his last few stops.” – Michael Street

On losing Franklin Gutierrez:
“Won’t hurt the Indians as much as it will help Seattle.” – Joe Hamrahi
“He’s a notch above a fourth outfielder, but he wasn’t going to replace Grady Sizemore in this universe.” – Michael Street

On losing Tom Mastny:
“Whatever they got from Yokohama will be worth more than what Mastny would have brought them in 2009.” – Michael Street

21. Chicago White Sox (Last Published Update - #14)

This Update’s Moves
- Claimed Kelvin Jimenez off of waivers from the Blue Jays
- Acquired Brent Lillibridge, Tyler Flowers, Santos Rodriguez and Jon Gilmore from the Braves for Julian Tavarez and Boone Logan
- Lost Tomo Ohka to the Indians via free agency
- Lost Horacio Ramirez to the Royals via free agency

Summary: The White Sox made a trade with the Braves and lost Ramirez and Ohka via free agency which sent them down the rankings.

On adding Brent Lillibridge:
“Formerly raved about as a primo defensive SS, probably won’t hit enough to do much if he’s not any longer.” – Rob McQuown
“Maybe Lillibridge needed a change of scenery; could be a steal if he turns things around.” – Michael Street

On adding Tyler Flowers:
“Excellent hitting prospect, though unlikely to ever catch in the bigs. Check back in September of 2010.” – Rob McQuown
“A nice pickup who could step in when Pierzynski steps out in ‘10.” – Michael Street

On adding Santos Rodriguez:
“He’s still young, but he’s put up good numbers so far.” – Michael Street

On adding Jon Gilmore:
“Another good pickup for losing Vazquez, though he’s got a ways to go before he reaches the bigs.” – Michael Street

On adding Kelvin Jimenez:
“Claiming Jimenez, a middling pitcher, was a strange move by the Jays two weeks ago; it’s still a strange move by the ChiSox.” – Michael Street

On losing Julian Tavarez:
“Kenny Williams can be a magician, but does he have enough rabbits left to fill a rotation now?” – Rob McQuown
“Signals rebuilding again for the ChiSox.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Vazquez wasn’t a pitcher that they needed, particularly with all their minor-league pitching depth.” – Michael StreetOn losing Boone Logan:
“They may miss him, though they got plenty in return.” – Michael Street

On losing Tomo Ohka:
“Another inning-eater they won’t miss with all their young arms coming up.” – Michael Street

On losing Horacio Ramirez:
“Ramirez has never recovered from a shoulder injury that derailed his once promising career.” – Michael Street

22. Kansas City Royals (Last Published Update - #30)

This Update’s Moves
- Acquired Coco Crisp from the Red Sox for Ramon Ramirez
- Signed Horacio Ramirez to a 1-year, $1.8-milion contract
- Signed Doug Waechter to a 1-year, $640,000 contract
- Sent Jose Lugo to the Mariners for cash
- Lost Jeff Fulchino to the Astros via waiver claim

Summary: The Royals have been active this offseason and finally showed some positive movement with the addition of Crisp, Ramirez and Waechter.

On adding Coco Crisp:
“Doesn’t really make sense for the Royals.” – Bill Baer
“A solid move for the Royals who earn a little respect for building a big league lineup.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Won’t out-hit Gathright by much, so they must assume he can out-glove him. Not sure why the Royals wanted 1 year of him, though… it’s not like they’re going to compete.” – Rob McQuown
“Crisp gives them a genuine leadoff man and veteran CF; David DeJesus should benefit by shifting from both spots. Crisp-Aviles-DeJesus makes for a promsing 1-2-3 Royals batting order.” – Michael Street

On adding Horacio Ramirez:
“Cue up “Glory Days” (12-4, 4.00 in ‘03), and open the checkbook, Mr. Moore. At best, he’ll eat innings cheaply.” – Rob McQuown
“It’s a gamble on Ramirez, who pitched well in 24 IP for Kansas City. Not a good sample space, and not a good gamble, either.” – Michael Street

On adding Doug Waechter:
“Good bullpen filler at a cheap price. Will replace some of the innings they’ve traded away.” – Rob McQuown
“They didn’t pay much to find out if Waechter’s 2008 was a sudden improvement or an anomaly.” – Michael Street

On losing Ramon Ramirez:
“Promising young arm. While he’s just a non-closer, still hard to let a cost-effective arm depart.” – Rob McQuown
“They’ll miss him in their bullpen, but Crisp was a good return.” – Michael StreetOn losing Jose Lugo:
“He’s a lefty who throws strikes, but seems awfully hittable.” – Michael Street

On losing Jeff Fulchino:
“With his numbers, the Royals have to be happy that Houston took him off their hands.” – Michael Street

23. Florida Marlins (Last Published Update - #20)

This Update’s Moves
- Lost Doug Waechter to the Royals via free agencySummary: The Marlins took a little tumble when they lost Waechter, a free agent actually in their price range.

On losing Doug Waechter:
“As usual of late, Florida is overloaded with arms, he won’t be missed.” – Rob McQuown
“At such a cheap price, he seems like a perfect fit for this Marlins. He might cost $700,000 to replace and that’s $60k more than this club wants to spend.” – Brian Joseph
“He wasn’t bad last year–for the first time since 2003. No big loss.” – Michael Street

24. Detroit Tigers (Last Published Update - #16)

This Update’s Moves
- Acquired Edwin Jackson from the Rays for Matt Joyce
- Acquired Gerald Laird from the Rangers for Guillermo Moscoso and Carlos Melo
- Lost Edgar Renteria to the Giants via free agency

Summary: The Tigers filled two of their needs by adding Jackson to the starting rotation and Laird behind the plate. Unfortunately, the Tigers lost Renteria and now have to find someone to fill his spot. The trades netted a positive for the Tigers but the loss of Renteria saw their overall ranking drop eight spots to #24.

On adding Edwin Jackson:
“Peripherals were not very good. Defense could be nearly as good as great TB defense this year in Detroit.” – Rob McQuown
“The Tigers need young arms, and Jackson’s still got room to grow, though he’s been only moderately good thus far.” – Michael Street
“Better than what they have at the back end of the rotation.” – Brian Joseph

On adding Gerald Laird:
“Useful catcher who usually hits lefties. Plenty of minor-leaguers do the same and are waiting for a break.” – Rob McQuown
“Good addition for Detroit.” – Matt Sisson
“I like this move. The Tigers love it. Let’s see is they’re overreacting.” – Joe Hamrahi
“This is a plus for the Tigers.” – Brian Joseph
“Laird will get a chance to play full-time in Detroit, but he’s not likely to be all that impressive.” – Michael Street

On losing Matt Joyce:
“Power and defense make him a useful lefty bat in the Geoff Jenkins mold.” – Rob McQuown
“Joyce may someday start as a corner outfielder, but the Tigers have other options there.” – Michael Street

On losing Guillermo Moscoso:
“Far too old for his league for insane strikeout totals to be taken seriously, but keep him in mind.” – Rob McQuown
“They need to collect good young pitching, not trade it away.” – Michael Street

On losing Carlos Melo:
“Still too young to worry too much about losing him, but too much upside to trade for a guy like Laird.” – Rob McQuown
“He won’t be major-league ready anytime soon, but this is another hit to the Tigers’ shallow depth in pitching prospects.” – Michael Street

On losing Edgar Renteria:
“How ridiculous that people thought the Tigers would have the “Best Offense In History” in 2008. Renteria won’t be missed.” – Rob McQuown
“Edgar’s defense really fell off. Everett will be a nice defensive upgrade but don’t expect a .700 OPS.” – Joe Hamrahi
“He wasn’t all that good with the Tigers, but losing him opens a huge hole at short with no real major-league solution.” – Michael Street

25. Pittsburgh Pirates (Last Published Update - #23)

This Update’s Moves
- Acquired Jason Jaramillo from the Phillies for Ronny Paulino
- Lost Matt Kata to the Astros via free agency

Summary: The Pirates have been relatively quiet in the offseason (although they added Ramon Vazquez over the weekend). They swapped back-up catchers with the Phillies and not much else during the latest update.

On adding Jason Jaramillo:
“Probably will be as good as Paulino, and doesn’t use a 40-man roster spot.” – Rob McQuown
“Pittsburgh traded caddies with Philly because they were tired of Paulino. Jaramillo won’t be any better, though he might be worse.” – Michael Street

On losing Ronny Paulino:
“Eh.” – Brian Joseph

On losing Matt Kata:
“Close your eyes, put your hand in a bag of utility infielders, and you’ll likely pull out someone as good as Kata, or probably better.” – Michael Street

26. Tampa Bay Rays (Last Published Update - #22)

This Update’s Moves
- Acquired Matt Joyce from the Tigers for Edwin Jackson
- Lost Trever Miller to the Cardinals via free agency

Summary: The reviews were positive on the trade but some of the BDD contributors polled weren’t positive on the loss of Miller. The defending AL champions have their work cut out for them with the positive strides the Yankees and Red Sox have taken if they are going to hold on to the AL East.

On adding Matt Joyce:
“Joyce really improved his stock in 2008, and may provide the bat Floyd was supposed to be in 08, with better D.” – Rob McQuown
“Joyce may turn out to be the surprise acquisition of the year.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Joyce is a young, frugal option for a corner OF spot, which is perfect for the Rays.” – Michael Street

On losing Edwin Jackson:
“May actually be addition by subtraction, not even considering what they got in return.” – Rob McQuown
“Opens up a spot for David Price, not that Price wouldn’t have outpitched Edwin for the spot anyway.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Losing Jackson is too bad, but they’ve got this other guy named . . . I forget . . . David Price, I think?” – Michael Street
“I wish I could say don’t believe the hype about David Price and moving Edwin Jackson will hurt them but I actually saw both of them pitch.” – Brian Joseph

On losing Trever Miller:
“May cause a little pressure on the pen.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Miller is good, but they’ve got a ton of young pitching right behind him.” – Michael Street

27. Toronto Blue Jays (Last Published Update - #8)

This Update’s Moves
- Lost A.J. Burnett to the Yankees via free agency

Summary: It never looked like Burnett was returning to the lone Canadian team remaining in the Majors and with A.J. joining the division rivals that cycle was completed.

On losing A.J. Burnett:
“Note to GM’s: Injury-prone pitchers will only “opt in” if they are hurt, so giving them an “opt out” clause is very risky.” – Rob McQuown
“Tough to lose good young pitching, but Toronto’s stacked with young arms who may prove more durable than Burnett.” – Michael Street

28. Seattle Mariners (Last Published Update - #28)

This Update’s Moves
- Signed Russell Branyan to a 1-year, $1.4-million contract
- Acquired Jose Lugo from the Royals for cash
- Acquired Franklin Gutierrez from the Indians and Aaron Heilman, Endy Chavez, Jason Vargas, Maikel Cleto, Mike Carp and Ezequiel Carrera from the Mets in a three-way trade that sent J.J. Putz, Sean Green and Jeremy Reed to the Mets and Luis Valbuena to the Indians
- Lost Raul Ibanez to the Phillies via free agency
- Lost Eric O’Flaherty to the Braves via waiver claim

Summary: Short-term, the Mariners have taken a step backward but the deal they made with the Mets may benefit them long-term and removing Ibanez’s big line off of the payroll was also a plus.

On adding Russell Branyan:
“Nice free talent acquisition, though he’s getting a bit old.” – Rob McQuown
“Seattle fans should pray that Branyan is in some sort of a platoon, though they’re not paying him enough to start.” – Michael Street

On adding Jose Lugo:
“They might find a spot for Lugo at the big-league level if he can learn to miss more bats.” – Michael Street

On adding Franklin Gutierrez:
“Freed from Grady’s blockage, he should quickly earn his spurs as a top defender in CF, bat might be good enough.” – Rob McQuown
“Gutierrez can’t hit all that much, but he’s got glove, a more important factor in SAFECO.” – Michael Street

On adding Aaron Heilman:
“Many believe he’ll be a decent SP, despite the Mets’ position on the topic. We may find out in 2009.” – Rob McQuown
“The Mariners are hoping he’ll rebound, and he might.” – Michael Street
“Caution and optimism in the same sentence? It is Aaron Heilman we are talking about though.” – Brian Joseph

On adding Endy Chavez:
“Chavez/Gutierrez/Ichiro could be one of the best defensive outfields in history. Endy should end up elsewhere by August.” – Rob McQuown
“A fourth outfielder and defensive replacement, period.” – Michael Street
“Notice there is no ‘o’ in Endy Chavez. That’s not a mistake.” – Brian Joseph

On adding Jason Vargas:
“Nice quality arm at a cheap price. Depth at SP is always a good thing.” – Rob McQuown
“Vargas is a throw-in on this trade, and the Mariners can easily throw him out if he doesn’t pan out.” – Michael Street

On adding Maikel Cleto:
“A nice reload of their farm system, though he’s not really on anyone’s radar.” – Michael Street

On adding Mike Carp:
“Like Branyan, Carp can hit everyone except southpaws. If one was a mirror image of the other, this would be genius. Right now, both moves are a bit of a puzzler.” – Michael Street

On adding Ezequiel Carrera:
“Carrerra may make an impact someday, but he’s still awfully young.” – Michael Street

On losing J.J. Putz:
“His loss will really damage the win total in ‘09, though winning 82 games is little better than winning 75.” – Rob McQuown
“New front office is cleaning house and starting from the bottom. Don’t think they got enough for Putz who would have commanded a much higher price at the trade deadline.” – Matt Sisson
“They unloaded him early. Coming off an injury year, maybe they knew something we don’t. If not, probably not the best move.” – Brian Joseph
“Putz is a big loss, but it was a gamble Jack Z had to take. Brought back some high upside younger players.” – Joe Hamrahi
“Another painful loss that had to happen, Putz’s absence leaves a big hole at the end of Seattle’s pen.” – Michael Street

On losing Sean Green:
“Cheap, useful arm… but replaceable.” – Rob McQuown

On losing Jeremy Reed:
“Cheap, useful 5th OF… but replaceable.” – Rob McQuown
“Reed had worn out his welcome in Seattle and went from centerfielder of the future to centerfielder of the past.” – Michael Street

On losing Luis Valbuena:
“It’s unlikely that either he or Lopez could handle SS, so he was a bit redundant, though lefty-hitting infielders are useful.” – Rob McQuown
“They had to give up some prospects, I suppose, and Valbuena was a pretty good one.” – Michael Street

On losing Raul Ibanez:
“A fine hitter who should have been converted to full-time DH (or 1B?) years ago. Also, a classy guy who will be missed.” – Rob McQuown
“Though they couldn’t afford him and need to build for the future, the Mariners will miss Ibanez on and off the field.” – Michael Street

On losing Eric O’Flaherty:
“What is it about the M’s and letting talent escape? Not a world-beater, but a good young arm who’s had success in the past. Oh, and a lefty!” – Rob McQuown
“His bad 2008 made the Mariners give up on him, probably too soon.” – Michael Street

29. Cincinnati Reds (Last Published Update - #26)

This Update’s Moves
- Signed Ben Davis to a Minor League contract
- Acquired Ramon Hernandez from the Orioles for Ryan Freel, Justin Turner and Brandon Waring
- Re-signed Mike Lincoln to a 2-year, $4-million contract
- David Weathers accepted arbitration offered
- Lost Jeremy Affeldt to the Giants via free agency
- Sent David Patton to the Cubs for cashSummary: The consensus is that the Reds overpaid for Hernandez and some think they overpaid to bring back Lincoln too. Losing Affeldt was also costly and probably one of the reasons the club offered Weathers arbitration.

On adding Ben Davis:
“If former major-league catcher (and major-league bust) Davis returns to the bigs as a pitcher, Disney will be begging for the movie rights.” – Michael Street
“Every time I eat a cheese steak at one of my favorite sandwich shops, I think of Ben Davis. He’s on the wall there. I am not one to eat at any fancy establishments.” - Brian Joseph

On adding Ramon Hernandez:
“What was wrong with Javier Valentin and David Ross? Dusty didn’t use them, then Walt let them walk. No improvement here.” – Rob McQuown
“Not a bad catcher but he’s getting older and skills have been on the decline for a number of years.” – Matt Sisson
“Good to get him at a discount–Baltimore will eat part of his salary–but he’s not the All-Star he once was.” – Michael Street
“Not as good as he once was.” – Brian Joseph

On retaining Mike Lincoln:
“$4 million?!?!” – Rob McQuown
“Lincoln’s the baseball equivalent of the coin embossed with his presidential namesake: cheap and so useless you find them lying around everywhere.” – Michael Street

On retaining David Weathers:
“The poster child for the “Anyone Can Close” movement, Weathers at least doesn’t entirely embarrass himself.” – Michael Street

On losing Ryan Freel:
“It’s unclear why this guy never got a shot at full-time CF duty in Cincy. Hairston does a lot of the same things now.” – Rob McQuown
“Plenty of Cincy pitching prospects who are better than this one.” – Michael Street

On losing Justin Turner:
“They didn’t expect much from Turner, who is a very replaceable prospect.” – Michael Street

On losing Brandon Waring:
“Too soon to know if Waring will reach his high ceiling, but they might regret this one day.” – Michael Street

On losing Jeremy Affeldt:
“Underrated left-hander with good L/R splits.” – Bill Baer
“Reportedly, Jocketty was surprised at how quickly he signed. Replaceable lefty at the cost, though there are indications he’s improved.” – Rob McQuown
“He’s had a couple of decent years with a platoon split that’s surprisingly even. A slight loss to the Reds’ pen.” – Michael Street

On losing David Patton:
“Plenty of Cincy pitching prospects who are better than this one.” – Michael Street

30. Milwaukee Brewers (Last Published Update - #11)

This Update’s Moves
- Signed Jorge Julio to a 1-year, $950,000 contract
- Re-signed Mike Lamb to a 1-year, $400,000 contract
- Lost CC Sabathia to the Yankees via free agency
- Lost Russell Branyan to the Mariners via free agency

Summary: The Brewers took the biggest hit of the offseason when Sabathia said, “Show me the money!” Now, the Brew Crew have at least one gaping hole to fill in their rotation and while the signing of Julio should help the back end of their bullpen, it doesn’t do anything to replace Sabathia.

On adding Jorge Julio:
“Has tantalized with his promise, but never quite put it together… a decent gamble.” – Rob McQuown
“Julio has made a career out of a 1.99 ERA in 2001, and that silly “closer” label. Paying any price for him is dumb, but $950K is moronic.” – Michael Street

On retaining Mike Lamb:
“Lamb is a nice pickup at a cheap price, as long as he’s rarely in the starting lineup.” – Michael Street

On losing CC Sabathia:
“One of the most impactful players in the game today.” – Rob McQuown
“Sabathia brought people to the ballpark in Mil but there was little the Brewers could do to compete with New York’s offer.” – Matt Sisson
“Quite possibly the team MVP. Creates a huge hole at the top of rotation and emotional presence is lost.” – Joe Hamrahi
“The Brewers lose perhaps their best pitcher ever. Hope they enjoyed that half-season rental, though they never could have afforded to keep him.” – Michael Street

On losing Russell Branyan:
“Letting Branyan go to keep Lamb seems questionable at best.” – Rob McQuown
“Branyan means “pure platoon power” in Moldavian. Losing him is losing half of a third baseman.” – Michael Street